Months ago I started playing Wild ARMS curious how the videogame has managed to build the respect of one of my favorite YouTubers. I have defeated the last of the storyline bosses and watched the final cutscenes, so I’d like to spill some more thoughts on the game, the first in series that’s but a minor player in JRPG history. These thoughts do consider Wild ARMS in their place in videogame history, yet I’m not judging this game as if I were playing it when it came out, but rather what it is like to play it now. Ultimately, seeing Wild ARMS through wasn’t about the design or the themes, but what it means for me to play a videogame just because.
I’d heard the music and felt I had to try the game out. I hadn’t grown up with a PlayStation and I was sure I had missed a lot of gems, this perhaps being one of them. Poking around forum showed that fans compared the Wild ARMS series to the Lufia series, which is among my personal favorites. The start of Wild ARMS was promising, with a cast of characters that exhibited signs of forethought. Each of the three main characters is revealed through a personal vignette defines the game as character-based as opposed to gameplay-based or otherwise. Each had personality quirks that endeared me to them and piqued my interest further. I was excited for what lay ahead.
Now, after spending thirty plus hours with Wild ARMS, I understand why these moves were made—the gameplay isn’t complex nor engaging. The thing about a character-based game is that those characters need to be gripping through their complexity and growth, but Cecilia, Jack, and (holy shit) Rudy are hollow and their motives are otherwise unclear. Shit, unclear isn’t the half of it when it comes to the game’s themes, but I’m getting ahead of myself. Yet I’ll say this: for as bad as it was, I played Wild ARMS through and enjoyed it. I’m trying to figure out what drove me.
I didn’t push through because of Lufia. For as intimate a knowledge as I have of Lufia, Lufia this game ain’t. Lufia II was a special game due to the quality translation of a decent story and the complex puzzles that barred access to dungeon bosses. Wild ARMS features neither of these. The translators knew the key to the game was to inject personality into the characters and at various times their efforts show this. Cecilia loves hamburgers, while Jack tends to be cocksure and act before he thinks. Still, these characters don’t have the same impact that you’d suspect as what’s established in the beginning isn’t threaded through the entire game. The character’s flaws are apparent at the beginning but only resolved thirty hours later with loose nods towards minute character growth throughout. For example, Cecilia frets that her royal position makes her a both unapproachable and utterly responsible for the lives of the world—she is Atlas holding up the world. As the game progresses, she continues to feel pained by the burden that she believes that is hers alone. Only in the final couple cutscenes does she relinquish this self-imposed weight when it is clear that she’s not alone in the fight. Christ’s sake, there are two people next to you in every damn fight that are slaying for the sake of peace! Over the course of thirty hours, these traits should have long since been honed and new personal dilemmas developed, but the pacing of the game crawls.

Rudy is a turd.
Moreover, there’s many times where the attempt at a quirky tone falls flat. Motivations for individual comments are often left to “I didn’t understand what to do, so I just worked hard!” which may be a character trope in popular anime and manga in Japan, but comes across as silly or stupid to an American reader. The mouse Hanpan is totally underused as a comedic foil for the bumbling Jack and Calamity Jane’s bombast contrasted with Rudy’s muteness only shines a putrid light on the silent protagonist staple. Reading up on the efforts that modern publishers (Nintendo, Xseed, Atlus) take in order to make videogames appeal to an American audience suggests that Sony either didn’t have the money or the time to provide for a quality Wild ARMS translation. This, to be clear, is not judging the past by the present; Natsume did an incredible job with Lufia II and Working Designs was killing is with Alundra and (from what I’m told) the Lunar series. While JRPGs have their wealth of blah-dy blah “spoony bard” bits, Wild ARMS came out in 1997, the same year as Final Fantasy VII. So-so characters with little development over the course of the game spouting stilted dialog as they conquer foes with unclear motives shouldn’t have hacked it then and doesn’t stand up well today. The poor translation is a bitter, bitter pill to swallow.
The puzzles of Wild ARMS also pale next to its contemporaries. Much of the latter challenge in the game comes from simply navigating the confusing dungeon layouts, as paths cross to and fro with little to differentiate them. The characters are given multiple tools but often only used in very specific circumstances, such as the water jug to put out very obvious in-the-way fires. I wouldn’t say the game has more than a handful of events that actually call you to use your noggin, which is a damn shame given the toolset that is available. How about use the water jug to fill containers that need to weigh different amounts? What if you needed to run water down select tributaries? Maybe you might throw some water on the face of a passed out prisoner? Anything other than just put out small fires. That’s just one item. The game manages the staples of battles in JRPGs, but even that isn’t done well. Every one of them is “find the weakness, heal the damage.” Each character has one action unique to them, only one or two honestly useful spells. The only thing that is remotely clever is how devastating the “sleep” affliction is in Wild ARMS, but once you’ve got that figured out, there’s not much left. No hidden conceits beyond “sleep.” Simply spam high attack power non-elemental spells and never looking back. Nothing about the game is engaging, which is a plus for many action games—I often play Super Mario when I just want to tune out for a while. I don’t think I’m alone though, that a JRPG should engage me. That’s why people are in love with the Job system in JRPGs. That’s why people are digging Bravely Default. The battles are a big part of what makes the Mario & Luigi videogames so fun. The systems in Wild ARMS are so damn boring.
But I played it through. I’m thinking back and there are so many good videogames I’ve left half played. What is it that drove me through it? Part of my initial curiosity with Wild ARMS was with the “environmentalist themes” that are claimed on the series’ Wikipedia page. How does Wild ARMS show the theme? Is it like Final Fantasy VII, with a mega-corporation that sucking the planet dry of life? No, because metal demons really want to watch the world burn. What a joke. The ecological framework of the story is scant. Sure, the world has a lot of desert and the world of the Elw is more lush than the human world of Filgaia, but the people are never made to seem lacking for it. Nary an important character claims that they have to go hungry with a root cause of non-arable land. The state of the world has been desert-y since the last struggle of good and evil caused a cataclysm a thousand-some years prior and the reason the planet hasn’t been restored is because the humans of Filgaia just don’t have enough hope? Hope? That’s it? Not hard work? Not clean energy sources? Not window fucking farms? Just hope? Well shit, I’ve learned so much. I don’t want to blame a JRPG from 1997 for lacking conviction, but it’s contemporaries do demon tales better and ecological broadcasts way better. Wild ARMS tries to be both quintessential in play design and modern in thematics and fails at both.
I don’t hate Wild ARMS though. I think I even like it, though I wouldn’t recommend it to a friend. Hell, I’m currently playing Wild ARMS 2. So here’s my best stab, though it’s a digression and deserves a greater focus, perhaps in a future piece. I used to really like some of the RPG writers for Joystiq and Kotaku. They would write about their favorite games and what made them great, which I could often relate to even if it wasn’t a videogame I had previously played. But now so many internet folks talk about the problems with modern games, with remakes of their favorites, and with deviance from the classics of the genre. I’m not so sure that changing the sprites for the mobile remake of Final Fantasy VI is the worst thing ever. If I want to relieve the exact same experiences, well, the closest thing I’ve got is amply available. I could play my old copies of the game. I could emulate it on my phone. If a company wants to change things up, that’s on them to decide and me to choose whether that’s worth my cash and time presently.

It won’t be the same if you go back, but you’ll always have those memories.
I can’t buy that experience that I had when I was a child. The time when I could spend an entire month playing a videogame, devoting myself sleeplessly, feverishly to it is not something that I can manage as a working adult. I’ve got papers to grade and write, friends to hang with, relationships to keep. Videogames are now something I’m driving towards as a profession and that relationship requires something different than the adoration that I felt for it as a kid.
Maybe though, maybe I can approximate it. If I don’t retread the same videogame grounds again, but keep the spirit of the game there, I can find some of that joy that brought me to love the videogame medium so damn much. I look at Wild ARMS and all I see are flaws, but I like it. The terrible characters, miserable translation, boring gameplay, and poor integration of theme don’t matter to me if I can capture a little bit of that magic. Playing through it took months due to a life where you scrape for minute with a videogame, but those minutes were hunkered before a CRT TV with the mindspace devoted to the videogame and only that. It was good, old fun. The fun I had as a child, not filtered through rose-color as it might be with nostalgic games like Lufia or Final Fantasy. Not diminished by the designer’s lense I’m honing in my graduate studies. Not expecting this game to be exactly as I remember it, because I don’t. I could just play a game and experience it in the moment I played. Despite the flaws, the experience was good. Goo-oo-ood.
I hope Wild ARMS 2 treats me so well. I feel though that, even if it’s as flawed as the first one (which it seems like it will be, ugh), I’m gonna enjoy it. It’s no Lufia, but it’s a gem. A bright glowing, busy adult gem.